CHARLOTTESVILLE CIVIC
Historic Resources Committee

Historic Resources Committee

Fri, May 8, 2026

Agenda items
Vote records
Discussion summary
Transcript

Agenda items (88)

Procedural (88)
1ProceduralMust have buy-in from property owner
Any project or initiative requires formal approval and cooperation from the property owner.
2ProceduralApproval of the Agenda
Committee votes to approve the proposed meeting agenda.
3ProceduralMeeting Minutes April 10, 2026 [Attached to this agenda.]
Council members will review and approve the meeting minutes from April 10, 2026.
4ProceduralSchool related items need to go to School Board
Any initiatives or requests related to schools must be directed to the School Board for review and approval.
5ProceduralHRC Membership Changes
Council will discuss changes to the membership of the Human Rights Commission.
6ProceduralQualifications need to be set a. Significant impact b. Deceased minimum 5 years c. What is the education component? d. Research component? e. Petition component and/or Letter of Support or organizational tie f. What is the commercial/advertising impact?
Clear eligibility criteria are needed for honors and recognitions, including minimum time deceased (5 years), community impact level, educational components, research requirements, petition/support letters, and assessment of any commercial or advertising aspects.
7ProceduralNew member recruitment efforts
Council will discuss efforts to recruit new members for open positions.
8ProceduralDT Mall Kiosks & FOC Support [10:50, 10 minutes] HRC Minutes – April 10, 2026 (5.4.26) 2
Discussion of informational kiosks and signage on the Downtown Mall, along with funding decisions for these displays.
9ProceduralACHS Walking Tour Rack Cards [11:00, 5 minutes]
Discussion about rack cards promoting historical walking tours in Charlottesville.
10ProceduralLiberty Bell Replica [11:15, 10 minutes]
Council will discuss the Liberty Bell Replica, including its installation, maintenance, or placement in Charlottesville.
11ProceduralMonticello Historical Marker [11:10, 5 minutes]
Discussion about creating a historical marker for Monticello.
12ProceduralLiberty Bell Replica [11:15, 10 minutes]
Discussion and updates about a replica of the Liberty Bell.
13ProceduralStaff Updates
Committee staff will provide updates on current projects and activities.
14ProceduralReview update provided by E. Shillue
Council will review an update provided by E. Shillue on an ongoing project.
15ProceduralAnniversaries of Note [11:45, 15 minutes]
The committee will recognize and discuss notable anniversaries or milestones.
16ProceduralReview update provided by O. Brown
Council will review an update provided by O. Brown on an ongoing project or initiative.
18ProceduralCheck-in on communication with Fire Department
Council will check in on ongoing communication with the Fire Department regarding the Liberty Bell Replica project.
20ProceduralMay – Rose Hill
Council will discuss or plan a neighborhood walking tour or event at Rose Hill scheduled for May.
21ProceduralJune - Locust Grove (J. Trompetter)
Discussion of a June community event or project at Locust Grove led by J. Trompetter.
22ProceduralJuly - Lewis Mountain (B. Bergen)
Discussion of a July community event or project at Lewis Mountain led by B. Bergen.
23ProceduralSeptember - Martha Jefferson & Little High (volunteer needed)
Planning for a September community event or project at Martha Jefferson and Little High schools, with a volunteer coordinator still needed.
24ProceduralOctober - Barracks Rd/Rugby (L. Pola)
Discussion of an October community event or project at Barracks Road and Rugby led by L. Pola.
25ProceduralDecember – Belmont HRC Agenda – May 8, 2026 (5.4.26) 1
Scheduling and planning for the December Historical Resources Commission (HRC) meeting agenda.
27ProceduralOpportunity for join-internship – online system for BPAC walking tour flyers
Opportunity for volunteers to help develop an online system for organizing and distributing walking tour flyers for the Bicycle and Pedestrian Advisory Commission.
29ProceduralCourt Square Banners
Discussion of decorative banners or signage to be displayed at Court Square.
30ProceduralArchival project update and visit from UVA special collections
Update on an archival preservation project and a visit from University of Virginia special collections staff.
31ProceduralOther staff information - TBD
Additional staff announcements and information to be determined.
33ProceduralEducation
Category for HRC activities related to education and outreach.
34ProceduralPublic commemoration (historic plaques, signs, markers, and civic festivals and ceremonies)
Category for HRC activities related to public commemoration, including historic plaques, signs, markers, and civic festivals.
35ProceduralPublications (maps, brochures, tour books, and digital media)
Category for HRC publications such as maps, brochures, tour books, and digital media.
36ProceduralPublic meetings (planning sessions, workshops, and lectures)
Category for HRC public meetings including planning sessions, workshops, and lectures.
37ProceduralAnd through other means. * Regarding public comment(s). The HRC values community participation and input and welcomes public comments at meetings. At the beginning of each meeting, not more than 10 minutes will be allowed for the introduction of any guests and public comments. Speakers may speak for a maximum of two-minutes and shall begin by identifying their name and address. The intent is to allow public input; not initiate a dialogue or debate with the committee. Subsequent to this meeting segment, by majority approval the HRC may amend the agenda to allow further discussion; however, the motion should also establish a time limit for that discussion. Additionally, prior to adjourning--and applying the conditions above--the HRC may allow a period not to exceed five minutes for public comment. **Individuals with disabilities who require assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public meeting may call the ADA Coordinator at (434) 970-3182 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov . The City of Charlottesville requests that you provide a 48 hour notice so that proper arrangements may be made. HRC Agenda – May 8, 2026 (5.4.26) 2
Guidelines for public comment at HRC meetings, including accessibility accommodations and procedures for resident participation.
40ProceduralModification of agenda to include two new items i. Court Square banners ii. Adopting virtual updates
Committee considers adding two new items to the agenda: Court Square banners and adopting virtual updates for meetings.
43ProceduralRepresentative of Preservation Piedmont
A representative from Preservation Piedmont will address the council.
44ProceduralConcerns about Wertenbaker House and final resolution
The council will discuss concerns about the Wertenbaker House and work toward a final resolution.
45ProceduralDominion sent letter about Charlottesville to Gordonsville transmission line i. We’d like to see it be the “most attractive” utility and would like to see the City take some interest regarding appearance of line [and location] ii. Staff response: Jeff Werner asks if it will be Cor-Ten Steel. GK does not know if what it will look like
Dominion Energy has requested that the city take interest in making the new Charlottesville-to-Gordonsville power transmission line visually attractive and appropriately located; staff will investigate what materials and design will be used.
46ProceduralSpecifics on BAR guideline updates and revisions to Tier 3 Chair recognizes 3 UVa students attending from their Democracy in Action class
The council will review specific updates and revisions to the Board of Architectural Review (BAR) guidelines, particularly for Tier 3 properties, with UVa students observing as part of a Democracy in Action class.
48ProceduralGeneral update – L. Pola & D. Berry The Downtown Mall 50th Anniversary survey has closed with 57 responses. L. Pola and D. Berry reviewed and narrowed the submissions to a curated set of comments, then shared for consideration. The group’s primary goal is to finalize which quotes will appear across seven kiosk panels along the Mall.
A survey about Downtown Mall memories has closed with 57 responses, and staff have selected the best quotes to display on seven kiosk panels throughout the Mall.
49ProceduralPanel design will include both images and text, with a target of ~80 words per panel (maximum ~200), ensuring readability and visual appeal. Names of respondents will be HRC Minutes – April 10, 2026 (5.4.26) 1 included when available, and all images must be copyright-approved. While business names may appear in quotes, they will not be used for promotional purposes.
The kiosk panels will feature both photos and text (about 80 words per panel, up to 200 maximum) with respondents' names when available; all images must have copyright approval and business names will not be used for promotional purposes.
50ProceduralMembers supported the selected quotes and discussed their placement sequence, starting at the Old Preston/Omni entrance. A subcommittee will work with staff to pair images with quotes and produce the kiosk signage, incorporating the “Cville 50th” branding developed by Friends of Cville. Materials must be finalized within two weeks to meet printing timelines (estimated 2–3 weeks) with Frontrunner Signs.
A subcommittee will match selected quotes with images and work with a printer (Frontrunner Signs) to produce the kiosk signs with 'Cville 50th' branding within two weeks to meet printing deadlines.
51ProceduralAdditional considerations include promoting the exhibit, notifying selected respondents, and sourcing images from media outlets and walking tour archives. Project logistics (image collection, branding assets, kiosk dimensions, and shared files) are being coordinated among staff.
Staff will promote the exhibit, notify people whose quotes were selected, gather images from media outlets and walking tour archives, and coordinate logistics including branding assets and kiosk specifications.
52ProceduralFinally, recollections are being documented and archived, including Reddit responses curated by L. Pola and organized in a spreadsheet.
Memories and reflections about the Downtown Mall, including responses from Reddit, are being documented and organized in a spreadsheet for the archive.
54ProceduralUpdate – E. Shillue Event in 2:00pm June 6, 2026 about Sarah Anne Kelly: Becoming Visible; bust unveiling and preview of documentary in the Swanson Room at Central Library
An event on June 6, 2026 at 2:00 pm will unveil a bust of Sarah Anne Kelly and preview a documentary about her at the Central Library's Swanson Room.
55ProceduralPartnering with Central Library to display the bust during the summer along with books about
The Central Library will display the Sarah Anne Kelly bust during the summer alongside books related to her story.
56ProceduralBust and display will travel around (ACHS, and then…before becoming a permanent display)
The bust will travel to multiple locations, including the Afro-American Historical and Genealogical Society (ACHS), before settling in a permanent home.
57ProceduralDr. Shelley Murphy will be unveiling Sarah Kelly’s ancestry to her (all about Apostle Kelly becoming visible) Thursday, May 14th, 6:00 pm at The Center: Shining Light of Charlottesville’s Hidden History
Dr. Shelley Murphy will present on Sarah Anne Kelly's ancestry and the history of Apostle Kelly on Thursday, May 14th at 6:00 pm at The Center: Shining Light of Charlottesville's Hidden History.
58ProceduralFormat is Beloved will show the short video then followed by speaker related to each video. Monday, April 20th at 12:00 Lunch and Learn hosted by Center for Teaching Excellence (CTE); ethical partnership
The Beloved Cville project will show short videos followed by related speakers; the first event is a Lunch and Learn at the Center for Teaching Excellence on Monday, April 20th at 12:00 pm focusing on ethical partnerships.
59ProceduralMC Follett
MC Follett will serve as emcee for a Beloved Cville event.
60ProceduralMelissa Levy HRC Invitation: E. Shillue is considering how to [add to this format of creating sculpture to create a collection]
E. Shillue is exploring how to expand the sculpture project to create a collection of similar historical busts and is considering this as an invitation for discussion with the HRC and other participants like Melissa Levy.
62ProceduralUpdate – O. Brown Test of Time Award presented to Congregation Beth Isreal
The O. Brown Test of Time Award was presented to Congregation Beth Israel.
63ProceduralM-F 9 to 5 about Charlottesville in the 1970s *New item
Discussion of a documentary or project called 'M-F 9 to 5' about Charlottesville's history in the 1970s.
64ProceduralCould we consider sending out simple updates about events?
Proposal to have the city send regular updates to residents about upcoming community events.
65ProceduralACHS, Beloved, others will provide simple event updates
Local organizations including the Albemarle County Historical Society and Beloved will provide simple event updates to the community.
66ProceduralThe group agreed virtual updates are a positive step; the Chair will coordinate with those representatives monthly prior to each meeting.
The group endorsed virtual event updates as beneficial, with the Chair committing to coordinate monthly with participating organization representatives before each meeting.
68ProceduralFunding item/allocation Motion by B. Bergen to allocate $3,500 to fund the kiosk signs on the Downtown Mall for the 50th
A motion to allocate $3,500 to fund kiosk signs on the Downtown Mall for a 50th anniversary project.
70ProceduralFunding item/allocation O. Brown will be placing the Walking Tour Cards in various tourism racks
Walking tour promotional cards will be distributed to tourism racks throughout the city.
72ProceduralFunding item/allocation Small sample of artifacts will be retained and placed on exhibition in the new Courthouse Remaining 37,000+ artifacts, working with Ben Ford (Rivanna Archaeological Services)
A sample of Swan Tavern artifacts will be displayed in the new Courthouse, while the remaining 37,000+ artifacts will be handled by a professional archaeological services firm.
73ProceduralUVa declined stewardship/curation
The University of Virginia declined to take responsibility for storing and preserving the Swan Tavern collection.
74ProceduralDHR will accept with a $14,000 i. Albemarle County will not contribute ii. Access can be given to public upon request (i.e. Special Collections)
The Department of Historic Resources will accept stewardship of the Swan Tavern artifacts for $14,000, with Albemarle County declining to contribute funding and public access available by request.
75ProceduralJ. Werner requested a $5,000 donation from HRC
A request was made for the Historic Resources Commission to donate $5,000 to support archiving the Swan Tavern artifacts.
76Procedural$7,000 would come from Historic Surveys Fund Motion to approve $5,000 from HRC to support archiving Swan Tavern artifacts through DHR repository: B. Bergen.
A motion passed to approve $5,000 from the Historic Resources Commission to help fund the archiving and preservation of Swan Tavern artifacts through the Department of Historic Resources.
78ProceduralUpdate from B. Bergen Albemarle County HRC has decided nothing; they are in the midst of creating a marker policy.
The Albemarle County Historical Resources Commission has not yet decided on a Monticello marker and is currently developing a policy for historical markers.
80ProceduralUpdates and discussion Sub-committee met (members: Pola, Bergen, Martz, Basic) Fire Dept. was contacted by HRC but they have not responded. ADA improvements pending at Ridge St. Fire Station
A subcommittee discussed plans for the Liberty Bell replica, including outreach to the Fire Department and pending accessibility improvements at the Ridge Street Fire Station.
82ProceduralReview March discussion (see minutes, policy attached)
City officials will review discussion points from March and examine the attached policy to ensure alignment.
83ProceduralReview revised policy (Staff memo to be circulated at April meeting.)
Staff will present a revised policy for review, with supporting materials to be shared at the April meeting.
84ProceduralSnook remembers 2020 with deluge of requests
Discussion about the high volume of requests received in 2020 and how to manage similar future submissions.
85ProceduralAsked HRC to get involved to assist with requests HRC Minutes – April 10, 2026 (5.4.26) 3 Snook: once issued proclamations when he was Mayor
The Human Rights Commission has been asked to help review and process community requests, with notes on how such requests were historically handled through mayoral proclamations.
86ProceduralCH Brown 12th Street issue Jeff notes that historical markers need to go through City and DHR approval
Installation of historical markers on 12th Street must go through both City approval and State Department of Historic Resources (DHR) approval.
87ProceduralNau Center was Parks & Rec Considerations:
Discussion of the Nau Center as a potential location, with considerations about Parks & Recreation involvement.
95ProceduralApril – UVA North Grounds
April walking tour will focus on UVA's North Grounds.
96ProceduralMay – Rose Hill
May walking tour will explore the Rose Hill neighborhood.
97ProceduralJune - Locust Grove (J. Trompetter)
June walking tour will feature Locust Grove, led by J. Trompetter.
98ProceduralJuly - Lewis Mountain (B. Bergen)
July walking tour will cover Lewis Mountain, led by B. Bergen.
99ProceduralSeptember - Martha Jefferson & Little High (volunteer needed)
September walking tour will highlight Martha Jefferson and Little High neighborhoods; a volunteer coordinator is needed.
100ProceduralOctober - Barracks Rd/Rugby (L. Pola)
October walking tour will explore Barracks Road and Rugby neighborhoods, led by L. Pola.
101ProceduralDecember – Belmont
Procedural matter related to December scheduling or activities in the Belmont area.
103ProceduralReview of March discussion (see minutes)
Committee members will review discussions from the March meeting by reviewing the official minutes.
104ProceduralScoping the documentation effort (10th Anniversary of 2017) 2027 will be the 10th Anniversary of the Unite the Right Rally march in Charlottesville HRC ought to consider marking the anniversary [in terms of historical education about the event] Snook: business-owners are saying [no thank you, let’s move past this]
Planning how to document and potentially commemorate the 10th anniversary of the 2017 Unite the Right Rally in 2027, though some business owners have expressed concerns about marking the event.
105ProceduralOne woman show by Priyanka Shetty [#Charlottesville]
Discussion of a solo performance or exhibition by Priyanka Shetty related to Charlottesville.
106Procedural[possibly contentious with UVa?] Collections available from ACHS (Jalane and CBI), UVa Special Collections, Beloved Community did a walking vigil from Lee Statue to CBI to Court Square; involved people who felt the need to reclaim those spaces (song, prayer, recollections)
Possible collaboration with UVa and community organizations (ACHS, CBI) regarding historical collections and community walking vigils related to reclaiming public spaces in Charlottesville.
107ProceduralE. Shillue agrees with B. Bergen that any memoriam would be internal and powerful Charlottesville should not be doing anything (making statements, hosting memorials, etc.) as there are many fronts to that event. Was not only about antisemitism it was about more topics. Charlottesville City Council should not (nor HRC) have an official statement on the event.
Discussion of committee members' positions that any 10th anniversary observance should be private and reflective rather than an official city or HRC statement, given the event's complex nature.
108ProceduralSupport
Committee votes to support a proposal or motion.
109ProceduralTabled for May HRC meeting.
Discussion of the 10th anniversary commemoration has been postponed until the May HRC meeting.
111ProceduralEducation
Discussion of educational approaches or programs related to historical commemoration.
112ProceduralPublic commemoration (historic plaques, signs, markers, and civic festivals and ceremonies)
Discussion of public commemoration methods such as historic plaques, signs, markers, and civic events.
113ProceduralPublications (maps, brochures, tour books, and digital media)
Discussion of published materials including maps, brochures, tour books, and digital media for public education.
114ProceduralPublic meetings (planning sessions, workshops, and lectures)
Discussion of public educational events including planning sessions, workshops, and lectures.
115ProceduralAnd through other means. * Regarding public comment(s). The HRC values community participation and input and welcomes public comments at meetings. At the beginning of each meeting, not more than 10 minutes will be allowed for the introduction of any guests and public comments. Speakers may speak for a maximum of two-minutes and shall begin by identifying their name and address. The intent is to allow public input; not initiate a dialogue or debate with the committee. Subsequent to this meeting segment, by majority approval the HRC may amend the agenda to allow further discussion; however, the motion should also establish a time limit for that discussion. Additionally, prior to adjourning--and applying the conditions above--the HRC may allow a period not to exceed five minutes for public comment. **Individuals with disabilities who require assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public meeting may call the ADA Coordinator at (434) 970-3182 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov . The City of Charlottesville requests that you provide a 48 hour notice so that proper arrangements may be made. HRC Minutes – April 10, 2026 (5.4.26) 5
Clarification of the HRC's rules for public comment, which allow up to 10 minutes at the start of meetings with individual speakers limited to two minutes, plus optional additional time before adjournment, and information on disability accommodations.